中国科技期刊研究:2015,26(3):244-251
    PDF
eLife期刊特点及其学术质量
(1.Cell Research编辑部,上海市岳阳路319号31B楼401室 200031;2.Molecular Plant编辑部,上海市岳阳路319号31B楼410室 200031)
eLife: its features and the academic quality
(1.Cell Research, Rm 401, Bldg 31B, 319 Yueyang Rd, Shanghai 200031, China;2.Molecular Plant, Rm 410, Bldg 31B, 319 Yueyang Rd, Shanghai 200031, China)
摘要
图/表
参考文献
相似文献
本文已被:浏览 4167次   下载 1113
投稿时间:2015-01-21    修订日期:2015-02-04
中文摘要: 摘 要 【目的】为更好地促进我国科技期刊包括OA期刊的发展提供借鉴。【方法】从eLife网站导出其创刊至2014年的文章数据分析其发文量及发文学科,电话采访eLife作者、审稿编辑了解其审稿流程及特点,挑选30篇文章请6位专家评价其学术水平。【结果】eLife审稿特色在于审稿人之间可以交流互动,审稿编辑归纳最终的评审意见,送审至接受平均时间在90天之内,其发文学术水平相当于PNAS。【结论】eLfie采用专家办刊模式,调动科学家的积极性,为作者提供优质服务,同时打造了简单实用的期刊平台,但其花费巨大,后续如何维持其可持续性发展我们拭目以待。
Abstract:Abstract: [Purpose]To help to improve the scientific journal development in China, we performed an analysis of eLife, a recently launched open access journal.[Methodology] We analyzed the paper output and subject classification using data from eLife website, learned their peer-reviewing process by interviewing authors, reviewing editor and referees of eLife, and invited 6 experts in molecular cell biology to evaluate 30 papers selected from eLife randomly.[Findings]eLife has established a new approach to peer review, during which referees have the opportunity to discuss their comments before the editorial decision is made. A reviewing editor oversees the whole peer-review process and assembles all comments into a single decision letter that clearly state additional data required for the revised manuscript. On average it takes about 90 days from submission to acceptance. The academic quality of papers in eLife is similar to that of PNAS.[Conclusions]eLife adopts a consultation session among the reviewing editors and referees, which greatly facilitates the decision process and provides a better experience for authors. It will be interesting to see whether its operation model is sustainable in the future.
文章编号:     中图分类号:    文献标志码:
基金项目:中国科学院自然科学期刊编辑研究会项目“eLife期刊特点及其学术质量”;国家自然科学基金重点学术期刊项目“Cell Research”(项目编号:31224802)
引用文本: